Gift card rules follow your Black Friday cards into 2031

A five-panel comic about one $100 gift card, from a Black Friday sale to a drawer in 2031, and the rules it meets on the way.

Chirag Bhavsar 5 min read ·
A hand holding up a small gift card box wrapped in plaid paper and tied with a red ribbon, warm string lights blurred behind it
Photo: Unsplash

The core gift card rules fit in one breath. Under federal rules, the money on a gift card you sell can’t expire for at least five years, and in California a gift card can’t carry an expiration date at all.

The trouble is everything around them. The bonus card in your Black Friday promo. The customer who wants the last few dollars back in cash. The card someone finds in a drawer years from now.

And people want gift cards. In NRF’s holiday survey, 47% of US adults said they’d like to receive one this season, the top answer on the list.

So here’s the life of one card, in five panels. The people are made up. The rules are real.

Comic panel one, tagged November 27, Black Friday. A stick figure named Jo, with a ponytail, holds a phone and says: $100 card for Ray, and a free $20 for me. Beside Jo, two hand-drawn cards: $100, labeled Ray's, paid for, and $20, labeled Jo's, free. A pencil note says two cards, two sets of rules.
Panel 1. Jo and Ray are our own made-up characters, and every amount in the comic is an example.

Two cards just left your store. One was paid for and one was free, and the rules treat them differently.

Ray’s card travels by email. When a gift card order is fulfilled, Shopify sends a digital card with a unique code, which also makes it the one gift that still arrives after your last shipping date.

Until Ray spends it, the $100 is a promise

Comic panel two, tagged same night, your store. A stick figure in an apron, labeled you, types on a laptop whose screen shows plus $100, thinking: best night ever. A pencil note beside the screen says an IOU until Ray spends it.
Panel 2. The money arrives tonight. The sale happens when Ray spends it.

Jo paid tonight, but nothing has left your shelves. Treat that $100 as money you’re holding for Ray, not money you’ve made.

It matters when you read December. A big gift card month can make sales look better than they were, until the cards come back as payments. Shopify keeps gift card finance reports for tracking card sales and the card payments on later orders.

Ask your accountant how they book the balance nobody has spent yet. Every card you sell this month is a small debt you carry into next year.

A bonus card can expire, but only if the front says so

Comic panel three, tagged the $20 bonus card. A large hand-drawn gift card reads PROMOTIONAL, $20, EXPIRES JAN 31, 2027, all in capitals. Jo stands beside it, surprised, asking: it expires? A pencil note says it can expire because the front says so.
Panel 3. An example card. The label and the date on the front are what let a free card expire.

Free bonus cards are the classic Black Friday gift card promo. They’re also where stores slip.

Under Regulation E, a promotional card skips the five-year minimum only if it carries the disclosures. The front has to say it’s promotional and show the date the money expires, and any fees have to be spelled out. Leave those off, and it may not count as promotional at all.

California is pickier about how it looks. A free promotional card can expire only if the date is printed in capital letters, at least 10-point, on the front of the card, per Civil Code 1749.5.

Shopify lets you set an expiration date on a card you create by hand. For a digital card, put the label and the date right where the code shows. We build stores, not legal opinions, so run the wording past your lawyer.

In California, a small balance is owed in cash

Comic panel four, tagged March, in California. Ray, in a beanie, holds a phone and asks: $12 left, can I get that in cash? The store owner in an apron answers: in California, yes, and holds out a hand-drawn check for $12.00. A pencil note says under $15 left? Cash, on request.
Panel 4. California’s cash-back line moved from $10 to $15 on April 1, 2026, per Civil Code 1749.5.

Since April 1, a California gift card with less than $15 left is redeemable in cash for that balance. The line used to be $10, and Morgan Lewis calls $15 the highest in the country. The firm says electronic gift cards are covered too.

“Cash” doesn’t have to mean bills. The statute counts a check, and a bank transfer works if both sides agree.

Your support team should know that before Ray asks. Other states have their own rules, so if you sell nationwide, check where your customers live.

Tonight, buy one of your own gift cards and open the email on your phone, the way Ray would.

The card has to work long after the promo is forgotten

Comic panel five, tagged November 2031. Next to an open dresser drawer, Ray holds up an old $100 gift card and asks: from 2026, still good? A speech bubble from outside the panel answers: still good. A pencil note at the bottom says the federal floor is five years.
Panel 5. Five years after the card is issued or last loaded is the earliest its money can expire, per Regulation E.

Federally, a fee for not using a card is allowed only after a full year with no activity, no more than one a month, and only if the card discloses it, per Regulation E. California goes further: no expiration date and no service fees, apart from a small dormancy fee in narrow cases.

Shopify’s default is the simple answer. Gift cards don’t expire unless you change the setting. We’d leave it there. A card that never expires and never charges a fee is the easiest rule to explain and the hardest to get wrong.

What to do this week

  1. Check one setting. In Shopify, open Settings, then Payments, then gift card expiration, and confirm cards never expire.
  2. Label every bonus card before Black Friday on November 27: “Promotional” and the expiry date, on the front, in capitals.
  3. Write the cash reply now. One message for “can I have the rest in cash?”, who approves it, and how you pay.
  4. Ask your accountant one question: how do we book gift card money nobody has spent yet?
  5. Sell the card at your cutoff. When your last shipping date passes, change the banner to “Too late to ship? Send a gift card by email.”

If you’d like bonus cards issued automatically with the label and date already on them, that’s the kind of thing we build.

A gift card is the easiest sale of the season, and a promise with your name on it for years.

Want an outside read on the rest of your store before the rush? Send us your store URL and within 24 hours we’ll send back a free report on your speed, checkout and conversion.